From the desk of Robb Wolf
Most people know a high-sugar diet isn’t healthy — it’s linked to obesity, diabetes, heart disease, cancer, cavities, and many other health problems. But that doesn’t make eating less sugar a cakewalk.
Eliminating sugar is hard. We’re wired to crave the sugary, hyperpatable treats that seem to follow us down every store aisle.
While we can’t rewire our brains to stop craving sugar altogether, we can lower the volume on those cravings. It helps to understand the root causes and triggers, and then let that psychology plus a little science inform the environmental, habitual, and diet changes we can make to reduce the cravings. In this article, I’ll talk through 8 of those changes:
Before we dig into this list, though, let’s start by exploring the roots of sugar cravings.
In past millennia, sugar cravings were useful. They encouraged our ancestors to scarf down sugary foods (like raspberries) and fatten up for times of famine. Humans even evolved a mutation that helped them store sugar as fat. The mutation provided a survival advantage, so now everyone has it!
But while our genes haven’t changed much since paleolithic times, our lifestyles and environments have shifted dramatically. We’re now surrounded by sugar-laden foods and drinks, allowing us to constantly indulge sugar cravings and store fat reserves many of us won’t ever need to tap into.
So which physiological and psychological mechanisms make us crave and overeat sugar? Let’s look at four of them.
Dopamine is a chemical that gives you a pleasurable feeling. Your brain releases it as a reward to reinforce (and motivate) “positive” actions and behaviors, like checking something off your to-do list or taking a quick jog. The body rewards us with a hefty dose of dopamine when we consume sugar, motivating us to keep eating sugar and store up for leaner times. And who doesn’t want a feel-good pick-me-up?
Picture a kid eating candy, bouncing off the walls, then suddenly crashing (and getting hungry) shortly after. These spikes and crashes in energy result from spikes and crashes in blood sugar. Put another way: Consuming refined carbs and sugar spikes blood sugar, and what goes up must come down.
Worth noting: “Carb cravings” and “sugar cravings” are not exactly the same thing, but they’re close. Sugar is a type of carb, and it’s processed in the body quickly, leading to those blood sugar spikes. Other refined carbs like pasta, white rice, and bagels can cause similar blood sugar fluctuations and cravings, so a lot of this article applies to those “traditional” carb cravings as well. More complex carbs like fruits, tubers, and vegetables contain fiber that blunts blood sugar effects and reduces cravings.
Sugar is one of three ingredients (along with fat and salt) that makes a food hyperpalatable, or super-stimulating to our tastebuds. We’re wired to crave hyperpalatable foods (again, to stock up on the calories), so we overeat them.
Super’s hyperpalatability is why food manufacturers put sugar in everything: soups, sauces, dressings, sugar-sweetened beverages, and more. The more we’re driven to eat these processed foods, the more we’ll buy. Sugary drinks alone may be the single most significant driver of the obesity crisis.
It’s also worth noting that sugar calories don’t fill you up. People who eat sugar before a meal consume the same amount of calories afterward as folks who ate a zero-calorie snack before — leading to eating more calories overall.
Rituals dictate our eating patterns. If you eat a cookie every night at 9:30 PM, the force of habit will stimulate cravings as the clock approaches the appointed hour. The more you consume a flavor or taste (especially a sweet taste), the more you desire it.
So, how do you stop desiring sugar?
Understanding the roots of sugar cravings helps you take steps to reduce them. The first tip below is the most difficult to implement, but also the most essential.
Remember how sugar makes your brain release dopamine, motivating future sugar consumption? Getting off the wheel of sugar intake breaks the dependency.
Eliminating sugar won’t necessarily be easy (sugar withdrawal symptoms are a real thing). But don’t give up if you’re initially uncomfortable, moody, or headachy. Give it a day or two, and stay hydrated with water and electrolytes to ensure dehydration or electrolyte deficiencies aren’t causing your symptoms.
Carbohydrates (especially sugar) are quick energy. When carbs are available, your body preferentially burns them over fat. Eating a low-carb diet trains the body to burn fat for fuel, reducing your body’s reliance on carbs.
Low-carb is a squishy term, though. A low-carb diet can contain up to 26% of daily calories from carbs, while a very low-carb diet like the keto diet generally contains fewer than 10% of total calories from carbs. On a low-carb diet, you’ll burn a mix of carbs and fat. On a keto diet, however, the body is forced to run on fat (a state called ketosis). Becoming “fat-adapted” on keto takes time, but both low-carb and keto reduce your reliance on sugar (and carbs in general) for energy. Being in ketosis also reduces hunger hormones like ghrelin and neuropeptide Y. Less hunger means less overeating, often leading to weight loss on keto.
Speaking of hunger, protein is the most satiating macronutrient (calorie for calorie). It triggers hormones that make you feel full and stay full. As such, high-protein diets are well-documented to reduce overall calorie intake and promote weight loss. As protein intake rises, sugar cravings should fall.
Sugar cravings are often salt cravings in disguise. When rats are salt deficient, brain cells that typically fire to reward sugary tastes fire to reward salty tastes. And sugar withdrawal and sodium deficiency symptoms (headaches, moodiness, insomnia) frequently overlap.
If you’re going low-carb to abate sugar cravings, you’ll want to pay attention to your sodium intake. Low-carb folks are at higher risk for sodium deficiency because:
Electrolyte drinks can help fill the gap. LMNT contains 1000 mg sodium and zero sugar — enough salt to make a difference, particularly in low-carb folks or sweaty athletes. Aim for the science-backed range of 4–6 grams of daily sodium and tweak from there based on lifestyle factors; you can also get an estimate of your daily sodium needs with our sodium intake calculator.
If you aren’t sleeping well, sugar will be irresistible. Why? Short sleep increases hunger and impairs impulse control. In other words, you’ll be both ravenous and impulsive when your colleague brings donuts to work. Dangerous combo.
Shoot for 7–9 hours of sleep per night, and guard this time ferociously. Your body will thank you.
Proximity and convenience matters. If you’re surrounded by sugar, you’ll eat sugar. If you’re not, you won’t. Ideally, keep sugary foods out of the house so that it requires effort and intention to go grab an ice cream cone, rather than the convenience of grabbing the tub from the freezer. If family or friends bring sugar into your orbit, do your best to hide it. Or find a new roommate.
It’s a universal truth that no system, organism, or process stays stable over time. This insight applies to life, emotions, aches, pains, and — yes — food cravings. They ebb, flow, and stabilize throughout the day — even when you don’t eat!
Case in point: Researchers found 36-hour and 12-hour fasts affect levels of the hunger hormone ghrelin roughly equally. In other words, hunger doesn’t increase infinitely. So, if you’re craving carbs, hang in there, and don’t fuel the urge by eating more sugar. The intensity will subside.
You can cut out sugar without neglecting your sweet tooth. Stevia, monk fruit, and allulose are all great zero-calorie sugar substitutes.
Sugary treats seem to be around every corner these days, but that doesn’t mean we need to listen to our hunter-gatherer instincts and indulge at every opportunity. The more we reduce our collective sugar intake, the more our collective health will improve. It won’t always be a cakewalk in the short run, but the long-term rewards for health and reducing risk of disease are more than worth it.